Rethinking What Counts as ‘Well-Treated’ Obstructive Sleep Apnea
- Comments Off on Rethinking What Counts as ‘Well-Treated’ Obstructive Sleep Apnea
- by SadofNE
A patient advocate realizes that perfect can become the enemy of good care for OSA patients who fail or refuse CPAP.
By Emma Cooksey | Original Post SLEEP REVIEW
Years ago, I got into a heated exchange with an Italian dentist on social media. I cringe when I reflect on it now.
The dentist shared that he had a patient with severe obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) who was unable to use his CPAP machine. Fitting a custom oral appliance, the dentist reduced the man’s apnea-hypopnea index (AHI) from the 70s to only nine events per hour. Instead of applauding a good outcome and the improved quality of life the patient was experiencing, I complained, “Obstructive sleep apnea isn’t properly treated until the AHI is under five events per hour.”
The exasperated dentist calmly pointed out that the patient had abandoned his CPAP therapy and had left his OSA entirely untreated before he got his oral appliance.
“Isn’t an AHI of nine with an oral appliance better than an AHI in the 70s with no treatment?” he asked.

Since this exchange, I have been ruminating on this question. In that time, I have recorded more than 140 episodes of my podcast, “Sleep Apnea Stories,” interviewing people living with sleep apnea about their treatment choices as well as experts from different specialties. I have learned so much about the broad spectrum of experiences in our sleep apnea community and the reasoning behind individual treatment choices.
I can understand the frustration of board-certified sleep specialists who prescribe CPAP therapy to their patients, only to see it abandoned. I am a huge advocate of more support and resources for new CPAP users struggling to adapt to their therapy. Early intervention with practical troubleshooting and empathy can be all that’s needed to take someone from giving up on their therapy to successful adherence. This could be a group CPAP therapy clinic for new users to get support in person, or an online coaching model similar to what companies like Lofta and BetterNight provide.
The very best sleep clinics offering superb support to new CPAP users still have a significant number of people who either never start CPAP therapy or abandon it over time. For those people who are leaving their OSA entirely untreated, we need a new attitude of pragmatism. Arguing that CPAP therapy offers the best results in people who use it isn’t helping the group who won’t or can’t use their machine.
The great news for patients is that the range of viable treatment options for OSA is expanding. The GLP-1 tirzepatide is already available as Zepbound, an injectable medication for people with both OSA and obesity. The oral pill version orforglipron has recently reported positive phase 3 trial results. Also in the “coming soon” category is Apnimed’s AD109, a once nightly oral pill that works to maintain upper airway muscle tone during sleep. The successful phase 3 trials for AD109 open up a whole new frontier of using pharmacotherapy to target the cause of OSA.
The dental sleep medicine community, not to be outdone, has been working hard on appliances with integrated SpO2 sensors. These oral appliances will enable the sharing of data, including wear time, oxygen desaturation index, pulse rate, and more, not only with patients but also directly with doctors.
Ear, nose, and throat surgeons have more techniques at their disposal than ever too. Top surgeons continue to refine throat surgeries to include new techniques like transoral robotic surgery. Hypoglossal nerve stimulation implants are evolving with the new Inspire V system with quicker surgery time and a Bluetooth patient remote. Nxyoah’s Genio neurostimulator just earned FDA clearance.
With so many treatment options currently available, and on the horizon, it is time we adopt a more pragmatic approach to considering a person’s OSA “well-treated.” Offering a treatment other than CPAP to lessen the severity of the OSA is far better for quality of life and health outcomes than no treatment at all.
As a patient advocate, I feel strongly that every person with an OSA diagnosis should be educated on and offered all the treatment options that could be useful to them.
I have, in short, changed my tune and now agree with the Italian dentist I argued with. I wish I could remember his name so I could apologize directly. Reducing the severity of obstructive sleep apnea and improving the quality of life for each individual is a worthy goal, even without hitting fewer than five events per hour.




